
It’s not charity if only some people are due help with true compassion. I heard this today on NPR’s Marketplace program and it made me throw up in my mouth a little:
Stickle applied for food stamps right after he was laid off. But he was told that he made too much money to qualify. Benefit Bank counselor Erin Sprouse says many people apply too early.
Interviewer #3: They take your last 30 days of income. So if you were just employed last week, then it looks like you’re making more money. But once you’re actually unemployed, lose that income, your eligibility changes.
She also helped Stickle fill out applications for assistance with the heating bill and home weatherization. Each year, in Ohio alone, a $1.5 billion in benefits goes unclaimed. Food stamps and children’s health insurance are two of the most overlooked benefits. And many families also miss out on tax credits.
A typical low-income family with kids that uses the Benefit Bank often gets about 15-thousand dollars worth of tax credits and untapped services.
Lisa Hamler-Fugitt: To date, we have helped low and moderate-income Ohioans secure over $100 million in public benefits and work support programs that help them meet their basic needs and weather the storm.
That’s Lisa Hamler-Fugitt, executive director of the Ohio Association of Second Harvest Food Banks — which manages and operates the Benefit Bank. She says the system for public benefits is fragmented and confusing.
Fugitt: For the new poor, they are very embarrassed. They don’t want to be seen at the local welfare office.
Hamler-Fugitt says people are more comfortable visiting one of the 800 Benefit Bank sites set up around the state in community centers and churches.
The whole thing is sad, yes, and the driving people to churches to get help is typical of this benighted excuse for a civilization, but it is THIS that made me feel sick and angry:
Fugitt: For the new poor, they are very embarrassed.
They don’t want to be seen at the local welfare office.
Why don’t they want to be seen at the welfare office? Because they don’t want to be one of THEM. You know, the “there will be poor always” people, the forgotten people, the by-definition BAD people, who somehow deserve their station in life. The people for whom the welfare offices have been made such hopeless, understaffed, unpleasant places. No, the “new poor” aren’t THOSE people. They’re “good” people who’ve had some bad luck, NOTHING like those people that have been neglected and mistreated and abandoned and shunned through the actions of our corporatist government. The government that is the “good” people and their votes and taxes and eager aping of the hateful rhetoric of the Rush Limbaughs and Bill Clintons and Barack Obamas of the world.
Oh, what … I can’t link Bubba and Barry to Rush?
“It doesn’t matter how much money we put in–”
“Come on now–”
“–if parents don’t parent.”
Shrieks and trills from every corner again interrupt.
“It’s not good enough to say to yourself, it’s the school, and you don’t turn off the TV, you don’t help with the homework, there’s not a book in the house–”
“COME ON NOW–” In my ear, she’s stentorian, bossy and encouraging, like a rancher birthing a calf. Will Obama be able to utter the truth? To get it out? She’s sure he has it in him.
“You got a video player on–”
“Come on, Obama! Come on, Obama! Come on!”
He is drowned by the roar, loud as falling water, and now the traveling press, realizing that something is actually happening, snap to. They sit up, swivel and stare. Unfortunately, the standing cameras are trained in the wrong direction, on Barack. One photographer hoists a big hand camera that he turns on the crowd, out of their seats and gesticulating, leaning forwards and back in a kind of a dance.
“So turn off the TV set, give the video game away, buy a little desk, or clear the kitchen table, from September help with homework–if they don’t know how to do it, give them help. If you don’t know how to do it, call the teacher. Make them go to bed at a reasonable time. Give them some breakfast. . . . If your child misbehaves at school, don’t cuss out the teacher. Don’t cuss out the teacher.”
“OBAMA! OBAMA! OBAMA!” These 750 in Beaumont are louder than the 20,000 in Houston’s Toyota Center last week. The din stuns. Stupefies. Really, there aren’t words to describe it.
A few minutes later, Obama, in answer to a question about diabetes research, tells the crowd, “we can’t keep feeding our kids junk.”
“Hold on! Hold on! Come on! TELL THE TRUTH!”
“Eight sodas a day . . . Popeye’s for breakfast.” He pauses and waits for a little opening. “I know some of y’all–” Obama speaking in Texas during the campaign
Never mind the factory food that is only available at overpriced fast food restaurant and tiny over-priced corner markets. Never mind the abandoned, overburdoned and underfunded schools. No, lazy poor people … it’s YOUR fault.
And those “new poor”, they’re NOTHING like those people … no no NO!
Americans, I suppose, aren’t special in this, but for a “christian nation”, we’re amazingly insistent that those for whom we show charity and compassion demonstrate that they deserve it, and when more of us fall into the abyss that is BAKED INTO the very structure of how this society works, those newly swallowed up are shocked and surprised to see the mess they allowed to fester out of sight and out of mind.
Was there a part of the Parable of the Good Samaritan where the Samaritan demanded a police report, income tax statement and a home visit before he gave aid that I missed? Not to throw their fairy tales back at them, but I’m pretty sure the Cosmic Muffin left that part out of the Book that he dictated to Luke.
This is not to say that I don’t feel for the “new poor” … I was one of them for several years, starting in 2001, right after Bush was installed into office. My unemployment ran out, after an extension, shortly before 9/11, and I was living in NYC at the time. I too remember my shock, once I did find (under)employment shortly before Christmas, at the condition of the NYC welfare office I visited to see if I qualified for a grant to help me catch up my back rent.
I saw hard-working people, proud people, people helping each other and trying desperately to make their way in a country that didn’t give a shit about them. I saw overworked, stressed out civil servants trying to stay ahead of a neverending wave of need that they didn’t have the resources to overcome. I saw paperwork and requirements designed to obstruct obtaining help, demands to go to multiple meetings and welcome home visits and answer infantilizing demeaning questions to obtain what people were, by law, ENTITLED to. I saw women, and they were mainly women, watching each other’s kids, and friends and relatives running in to pick up kids when the wait for help stretched to hours, and resilience and an incredible strength.
People shouldn’t be treated like that … not the “new poor” or the EVER POOR. NO ONE in a civilized, compassionate, DECENT country should be treated like that.
I’m sorry for these new victims of our rapacious capitalism, but their shame is a shame that many are subjected to throughout their lives, from cradle to grave, for want of one opportunity, one inate gift, one mentor or bit of luck … and who has that happen in their lives WITHOUT the balancing out experiences of loss and bad luck and ill health?
Our sainted President may have worked hard, but he was also LUCKY, the recipient apparently of a supportive family and successive mentors and teachers. How easy to forget that and pretend it was all the right choices and the harder work and the “god-given” gifts.
It is a sign of a deeply sick culture that the act of finding and receiving HELP is considered shameful, and even more sick that it is shameful to get that help from government structures but somehow more acceptable to accept help from tax-free cons that demand obedience and obescience.
That’s not charity … it’s control.
Hopefully some of those who’ve gone overboard will learn from the experience, if they climb back out again. The line between dismissive middle class and forgotten underclass is a fine, fragile boundary. Perhaps they’ll think that it might be easier to avoid embarrassment when help is needed by humanizing what passes for social services in this country.
I’m not going to hold my breath …